- 井の中の蛙 - http://www.froginawell.net/japan -

A memory stirs…

Posted By Jonathan Dresner On 12/24/2012 @ 2:16 am In Academia,Anecdotes,China-Japan | Comments Disabled

Reading Emily Whewell’s review of this new book on the Chinese and Japanese treaty port systems and extraterritoriality brought back a long-ago scholarly memory.

My first seminar paper in graduate school — that small snippet of scholarship which is supposed to prepare callow youth (intellectually speaking) for greater things, and scout a path through the existing forests of scholarship — was a comparison of the Chinese and Japanese treaty port systems. I remember very little about the paper, except embarassment.

I titled the paper something like “The Treaty Port Systems of Japan and China: A Fruitful Comparison” — and Cassell’s work, cited above, confirms my sense of topic, if not my other judgements — and in the end I came to the conclusion that the systems were, in fact, too different to be considered quite the same thing. In fact, I concluded, it was like “apples and oranges”….

It’s a wonder that I survived graduate school. I try to remember that when I’m evaluating my own students.


Article printed from 井の中の蛙: http://www.froginawell.net/japan

URL to article: http://www.froginawell.net/japan/2012/12/a-memory-stirs/