우물 안 개구리

3/26/2007

Remixing Tagore

Filed under: — Owen @ 8:15 am Print

This story in the Korea Times about Rabrindranath Tagore’s poem ‘The Lamp of the East’ caught my eye. In the South Korean nationalist imagination this poem has a remarkably important position as a sort of ‘external legitimator’ for Korean independence. But according to the KT, the version that appears in many of the nation’s high school textbooks has, shall we say, been remixed and enhanced:

…the poem titled “The Lamp of the East” seems to have been over glorified to the point where it has taken on a life of its own, spawning hundreds of different versions with stronger words and longer passages to boost nationalistic sentiment.

More specifically, it seems that an unrelated passage has been taken from Tagore’s poetry collection Gitanjali and added to his original poem about Korea published in the Dong-A Ilbo newspaper in 1929:

“The version of the poem that combines excerpts from Gitanjali has been widely spread for a long time and it is often mentioned by politicians and even newspaper columnists. There are even some literary schoolbooks that list the variation as the original version of `The Lamp of the East,”’ a high school history teacher in Seoul, who asked not to be named, said.

According the Wikipedia article about him, Tagore himself was not exactly the model independence fighter and was almost killed by Indian expatriates while staying in San Francisco in 1916 because of his apparent lack of devotion to the cause of Indian independence. In fact, from a strictly nationalist point of view you could say that he sounds a bit like Yi Kwangsu – a mixture of the good and the dubious. Interestingly enough the very comprehensive article doesn’t mention Korea once, so it would seem that the significance of Tagore for Koreans is not necessarily matched by the significance of Korea to Tagore and his legacy. Actually, one wonders whether it was in fact the strong impression made by the Koreans that Tagore met in Tokyo (Dong-A bureau chief Yi T’aero and poet Chu Yohan) in 1929 that moved him to write his famous-in-Korea poem as much as his feelings about a country he was never able to visit.

There are many fascinating aspects to this literary-historical episode: the creation of historical memory and national identity; the fundamentally non-self-contained nature of nationalism and its need for external legitimation; and questions concerning the malleability and authenticity of a literary text (especially when in translation). But perhaps what intrigues me most of all, is who actually came up with the idea of remixing Tagore’s poem in the first place, and why did they feel the need to do so.

In case people are interested, I’ve transcribed below the original text (with original han’gul spellings and hanja preserved – the jpeg was not too clear so I hope I’ve rendered the spellings correctly) of Chu Yohan’s translation of Tagore’s poem that appears in the picture of the Dong-A article provided by the Korea Times:

일즉이 亞細亞의 黃金時期에
빗나든 燈燭의 하나인 朝鮮
그 燈불 한번다시 켜지는 날에
너는 東方의 밝은 비치 되리라

English original:

In the golden age of Asia
Korea was one of its lamp-bearers
And that lamp is waiting to be lighted once again
For the illumination in the East.

For the sake of comparison, the extra 11 lines added from Gitanjali song 35 and included in the version of the poem known to many Koreans are below the fold.

마음에 두려움 없이
머리를 높이 치켜들 수 있는 곳
지식이 자유로울 수 있는 곳
작은 칸으로 세계가 나누어지지 않은 곳
말씀이 진리의 속 깊은 곳에서 나오는 곳
피곤을 모르는 노력이 완성을 향하여 팔 뻗는 곳
이상의 맑은 흐름이
무의미한 관습의 메마른 사막에 꺼져들지 않는 곳
님의 인도로 마음과 생각과 행위가 더욱 발전하는 곳
그런 자유의 천국으로
나의 조국이 눈뜨게 하소서, 나의 님이시어. [Some versions have: 나의 마음의 조국 코리아여 깨어나소서]

Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high;
Where knowledge is free;
Where the world has not been broken up into fragments by narrow domestic walls;
Where words come out from the depth of truth;
Where tireless striving stretches its arms towards perfection;
Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way into the dreary desert sand of dead habit;
Where the mind is led forward by thee into ever-widening thought and action –
Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake.

(Sourced from this useful Naver chisik answer)

4 Responses to “Remixing Tagore”

  1. justin says:

    this post is under my jurisdiction.
    wondering if this poem was directed for korea in the first place…..
    at least rest assured we got a good DJ-remix

  2. Owen says:

    I take it that I’m permitted to write about things in your jurisdiction Justin…

    The four-line poem quoted in its original form above was definitely written by Tagore ‘for Korea’ or at least for the Koreans he met on his visit to Tokyo in 1929. The story goes that he wrote it because he had promised Yi T’aero that he would visit Korea himself, but this turned out to be impossible so he gave him this poem instead.

  3. Uday says:

    The last 11 lines are known to us Indians as Tagore’s creation for India and the people of India. However, I do firmly believe that first 4 line poem is for Korea, a beautiful and enchanting country itself.

  4. [...] फ्राग इन ए वैल के मुताबिक चार पंक्तियों की यह कविता दक्षिण कोरियाई राष्ट्रवाद की कल्पना में कोरियाई आजादी आन्दोलन को जायज़ ठहराने वाली एक ‘बाहरी वैधता’ की  तरह बहुत महत्वपूर्ण ढंग से अंकित रही है. कोरियाई पाठ्यपुस्तकों में इस कविता को पढाया जाता रहा है. और यहीं से हमारी कहानी शुरू होती है. २००७ में कोरियन टाइम्स में एक लेख प्रकाशित हुआ कि हाई स्कूल पाठ्यपुस्तकों में इस चार लाइन की कविता का एक ऐसा संस्करण पढाया जा रहा है जो चार नहीं बारह लाइनों का है. रविंद्रनाथ ने कोरिया के लिए चार पंक्तियाँ लिखी थीं जो इस प्रकार हैं (अंग्रेजी में): [...]

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress